A manager opens the training report and asks a reasonable question: if the course says Completed, why does the next column say Failed? Or why do a dozen people show Incomplete when they swear they finished? These reports are not random. They follow rules, and the rules are written in two specific fields. Understanding completion status vs success status is most of the answer. Why does an LMS show completed but not passed, and how do you make the report say what you mean?

An LMS shows completed but not passed because completion and success are two separate facts: completion records whether the learner finished, and success records whether they met the pass mark. SCORM 2004 stores them in two fields, cmi.completion_status and cmi.success_status, so a learner can legitimately be completed and failed. SCORM 1.2 has only one field, cmi.core.lesson_status, so the course must pick one. Most confusing reports come from a mismatch between what the course sends and what the LMS displays. Fix that by deciding what "done" means, setting the course to send that, and testing the report before release.

Completion Status vs Success Status: What Is the Difference?

Completion describes effort; success describes performance. That distinction is simple to say and easy to lose in a busy report.

Why Does My LMS Show Completed but Not Passed? – Completion Status vs Success Status Explained - 3D Wireframe Animation
  • Completion status answers "did the learner do the required activity?" In SCORM 2004, cmi.completion_status takes the values completed, incomplete, not attempted or unknown.
  • Success status answers "did the learner meet the standard?" In SCORM 2004, cmi.success_status takes the values passed, failed or unknown.

The SCORM run-time reference lists these values for both versions. Note that "unknown" is a real value, not an error. A course with no quiz may never set success at all, and leaving it unknown is correct.

A short course that only requires viewing can be completed with success unknown. A compliance course with a test usually needs both: completed, and passed.

How Does SCORM 1.2 Squeeze Both Into One Field?

By making you choose. SCORM 1.2 has a single field, cmi.core.lesson_status, and it holds one value at a time. Four of its six values do the everyday work (passed, failed, completed and incomplete), while browsed and not attempted cover narrower cases.

That is why many authoring tools offer a publish setting for SCORM 1.2 with two modes, usually labelled something like "passed/failed" and "completed/incomplete". In passed/failed mode, a learner who scores below the pass mark is reported as failed, and the LMS has no separate record of whether they finished. In completed/incomplete mode, the quiz result may never reach the status field at all.

The other values have narrower uses. "Not attempted" is the starting value before a learner launches the course. "Browsed" was meant for a learner who views the course in a browse or preview mode that does not count, and in practice few courses set it. If a report shows browsed, look for an LMS setting that launched the course in that mode.

There is a further wrinkle. A SCORM 1.2 manifest can define a mastery score for a course. When it does, and the course reports a score, many LMS platforms will set passed or failed themselves by comparing the two, sometimes overriding what the course sent. If the course pass mark and the manifest mastery score disagree, the LMS usually wins. The broader differences between the versions are covered in the comparison of SCORM 1.2 vs SCORM 2004.

Why Does the LMS Show Completed but Not Passed?

Usually for one of four reasons. Each has a different fix, so it is worth identifying which one applies before changing settings.

SymptomLikely causeFix
Completed, success blank or unknownQuiz result never sent, often because the learner closed before the results slideSend the result when the quiz is submitted, not only on a later slide
Completed and failedLearner finished but scored below the pass markNone needed; the report is accurate
Completed in SCORM 1.2, no pass shownCourse published in completed/incomplete modeRepublish in passed/failed mode if the pass matters
Completed, but the dashboard hides successLMS report shows only one columnAsk the LMS admin to add the success field to the report

The second row deserves emphasis. A learner who views every slide and then fails the test has, in fact, completed the course and failed it. Reporting both is a feature. The question is whether your organization considers that learner done, and that is a policy decision, not a technical one.

Why Is a Course Stuck on Incomplete?

Because the course never told the LMS anything else, or told it and the message was lost. When an LMS shows incomplete, check these causes in order:

  1. The completion rule was never met. A rule like "view all slides" fails if one slide sits behind a branch the learner never took.
  2. The course sets completion on the final slide, and learners close the window one slide early.
  3. The status was set but not saved. The course must commit data and call LMSFinish (1.2) or Terminate (2004); closing the browser abruptly can skip this.
  4. In SCORM 1.2 passed/failed mode, some LMS views show a failed learner under an "incomplete" or "not complete" heading.
  5. The LMS requires both completed and passed before it marks the enrolment complete.

Cause three is a frequent culprit on slow or busy networks. Some courses only commit data at the very end, so if the final commit fails or never runs, the whole session's progress is lost. A course that commits after each important change, such as a quiz submission, is far more forgiving.

A test tool that logs every API call settles most of these quickly. If the log shows a SetValue for completed followed by a successful commit, the problem sits in the LMS. If it never shows the call, the problem sits in the course.

How Do Pass Marks and Results Slides Affect Status?

They decide when the result is sent and what it is compared against. In most authored courses, a results slide calculates the score, compares it with the pass mark, and sends the score and status to the LMS. If the learner never reaches that point, nothing is sent.

Take a labelled example. Say a course has a pass mark of 80% and a learner scores 75% on a 20-question quiz (15 correct).

  • SCORM 1.2, passed/failed mode: lesson_status is set to failed. Score raw is 75, with min 0 and max 100.
  • SCORM 1.2, completed/incomplete mode: lesson_status is set to completed, and the fail is visible only by reading the score.
  • SCORM 2004: completion_status is completed, success_status is failed, and score scaled is 0.75.

SCORM 2004 adds two settings that can override the course. The manifest can define a scaled passing score, exposed to the course as cmi.scaled_passing_score, and a completion threshold. When those are present, the LMS may judge success and completion from them. Keep the course pass mark and these values identical, or remove the duplicates.

Retries add one more question: does the LMS keep the first, best or last attempt? That is an LMS setting, so ask. The course cannot control it.

It helps to see the mapping in plain words before publishing. AuthorLearn Studio shows a plain-words box before publish that states how a given score will be reported, for example "A learner who scores 50% will be reported as Failed". It is a useful sanity check, and you still confirm the result in your own LMS, because the LMS has the final say on how it is displayed.

Completed and Passed Are Two Answers to Two Different Questions

Completion status vs success status is not a technicality. One field records whether the learner finished, the other whether they met the standard, and reports only make sense when everyone knows which column answers which question.

Decide what "done" means for each course. Choose the SCORM version and publish mode that report it, keep pass marks consistent between the course and the manifest, and send results at the moment the quiz is submitted. Then upload a test package, take it twice (once passing, once failing), and read the report the way a manager would. If it confuses you, it will confuse them.